The morning after the Colts' exhilarating Monday Night Football victory over the Miami Dolphins, the drive-time ESPN radio team of Mike Greenberg and Mike Golic devoted much of their four-hour stint to the game. It's sports-talk formula that people want to hear about what they saw and Monday Night Football is what every fan sees.
For those in Indianapolis who wanted to hear about what they saw, it would have been smart to skip Mike and Mike and tune in the next time slot on 1070TheFan: the Dan Dakich Show.
With a game that offered much to discuss: the "wildcat" offense, the Dolphins' clock management, the Colts' lack of run defense and Peyton Manning's magic audibles, Greenberg and Golic focused on one cockeyed point: is Manning a better Colts quarterback than the late Johnny Unitas? Despite the fact that Unitas played his last game in 1973, before many of the listeners were born, and that he never played in Indianapolis, the two Mikes went through "best quarterback" lists and belabored the question through live interviews. The simple answer is that the two football eras cannot easily be compared and they both will be remembered as among the best.
That simple answer did not suffice, because Mike and Mike regularly reduce every sporting accomplishment to a "best" list. Quarterbacks, pitchers, tennis players, coaches, shortstops. The question of whether Derek Jeter is better than Cal Ripken can be counted on to produce email and fit neatly into a short morning drive segment.
Dan Dakich doesn't have to worry about short segments. On the air now for nearly a year, Dakich runs his three hours like the family patriarch at Thanksgiving dinner. He's patient with kids, prickly with blowhards and lets guests and callers expound a viewpoint without confrontation or condescension.
When Emmis Broadcasting gave the 10 a.m. to 1 p.m. weekday slot to Dakich, some in the industry scratched their heads. Why move ESPN's national Colin Cowherd show out of its live slot to the afternoon for an old basketball coach who'd never done radio? The other sports radio stations in Indianapolis rely on their networks for mid-morning material. While Dakich spent 16 years as a player and coach at Indiana University, he'd been in Ohio for most of the previous ten years as the coach at Bowling Green University. He came back to IU during the Kelvin Sampson years and served as the interim head coach after Sampson was fired.
How long could Coach Dakich endure knucklehead listeners? Would every show devolve into a debate about Bob Knight? What if he had to talk about something other than basketball?
What's happened is that listeners have helped Dakich shape his show into something approaching a sports-talk salon. The games and schtick are minimal. The show keeps a moderate pace and and an Indiana center. Like most coaches, Dakich seems to be interested in all sports. Almost every coach you meet seems to be a fan of baseball and a player of golf. Pro football is the national sport; Dakich has baskeball covered and is the kind of guy who scans his car radio for high school games.
The morning after the Colts defeated the Dolphins, those who had the good fortune to tune in Dan Dakitch learned about the problems with the Indianapolis run defense and running attack, the former critics of Dallas Clark, the wisdom of "wildcat" and much more.
It's not formula radio. It may not survive. But for those with the time to listen, it's better than you would expect.
David Dawson